
So, The Doctor met his daughter. It’s really just a cheat. Everyone was expecting some insight into The Doctor’s family. Except for a few glib references, the only evidence of family was Susan, the even more mysterious granddaughter. The companion exists as a proxy for the audience to ask all those questions we’d otherwise be shouting at the screen. Susan was made The Doctor’s granddaughter to alleviate any implications that the somewhat elderly William Hartnell was a dirty old man traveling the universe with a fifteen year old bit of crumpet. As it turns out, daughter Jenny is not Susan’s mother.
Enough about that. How was the episode? To be honest, it was average. The second half brought back memories of “The Invasion of Time” with the group running through endless corridors and even running into the previously kidnapped companion. The alien antagonists, the Hath, are one dimensional, mostly unexplained and not overly imaginative. I wonder if the human colonists are referred to as the Hath-Not. Even the colonists aren’t fleshed out except for the leader played fairly well by the uniquely voiced Nigel Terry. The accent was triggering a feeling of deja-vu. Then I realized, this is a much older King Arthur from the excellent “Excalibur“. While effectively acted, the character is the typical selfish bastard, jerk that colonists from about 1,000 years in the future in the Doctor Who universe are. There’s even a sly reference to "The Keeper of Traken" with the plot device of The Source.
Now Georgia Moffett, who really is The Doctor’s Daughter, puts on a spectacular performance and she’s obviously loving it. While the bright spot of this episode, she reveals the casting error done in the first two series by giving the role of Rose to the dreary Billie Piper instead of this dynamo. We could have been spared twenty-seven episodes of Tammy Faye makeup and inaudible diction. She worked incredibly well with David Tennant even with an overwrought death scene in the mix. Fortunately, it turns out, she has enough in common that she doesn’t really die. (Why she managed to revive herself instead of regenerating into someone else will hopefully be explained in a future episode.) She really does need to be seen again as Jenny.
Speaking of companions, Freema Agyeman returns for the third of five episodes this series as Martha Jones. While I absolutely love Martha, Freema seems to have lost some of her enthusiasm for playing her. Fortunately she gets kidnapped early on and we only she her half assed, phoning it in intermittently. This leads us to the current companion, Donna Noble, played with a certain panache by comedian Catherine Tate. When Donna first showed up in The Runaway Bride, she was brash, grating and all around annoying. I don’t believe I was the only one who was not thrilled at the news of her becoming a regular. The producers gained the wisdom to tone this down and give her a Jiminy Cricket role to someone who is so old, damaged and jaded he can’t really see the little things anymore. For someone who can point a gun at someone’s head and state “I would never,” The Doctor’s reactions to devastation he is directly responsible for can be disturbingly nonchalant. During their first meeting, Donna told him he needs someone to stop him. Donna has been fulfilling that role spectacularly. I am really enjoing a companion who isn’t mushy for the Doc and can act with some objectivity.
One last thing about the good ol’ Doc himself: The survivor’s guilt that plauged the Christopher Eccleston version of the character seems to be returning. He enters, with far too much enthusiasm, every situation that can lead to his demise. Any mention of a topic that can remind him of his past seems to send him into a combination of anger and depression. Has spending so much time around humans made him too much like us? Or has Tennant, while certainly brilliant in the role, lost the ability to cast the alien aura the Eccleston was able to so easily project? Or maybe the writers are at fault…
Tags: British, Doctor Who, Science Fiction, Television by Dean
No Comments »